How did the supporters I do have come to support us? Identifying what we individually are doing and what the mission as a whole is doing that generates new relationships is a helpful exercise because it may lead to things that can bring replicated? It might also identify the fact that the truth is I really do not have new donors, we are not doing anything that has interested people to get involved in a fresh way in several years.
What are creative ways we can experiment to create more engagement, interest, friendship and encouragement?
Do donors have anything else to do other than give? Am I creating ways that people can get truly involved?
In non profits we are often experts at understanding the problem and solutions for a serious need. Maybe becoming that expert and reporting it gives a voice to new people. Our fundraising often devolves into just asking people to give. How can we amp up inspiring and educating. Encouraging other people that care about what we do to make it a part of their own missions.
Identify people you would like to meet and pursue them. As you say, in person is hard to beat. I always use a top 10 list every month. One thing on my top 10 every month is answering these questions, who would I like to meet and how can I get in touch with them to see if they will have a cup of coffee with me? The focus of always trying to meet new people is helpful for me. When it happens (and it sometimes fails) and I actually figure out how to get together, I usually just ask to hear their story, what things are they excited about and what things are they doing to serve Jesus. Over time this kind of works. Sometimes, by just knowing many people, they talk and it serves as a referral or a stamp of approval among community peers. It can create momentum and people come looking for you at times as opposed to it just being chasing.